GOP challenges to social conservatives on Texas education board could alter textbooks’ content

GOP primary could reshape Texas board, textbooks

SAN ANTONIO — What millions of students read about science and history could hinge Tuesday on a Republican primary in Texas for several seats on the state board of education, a panel whose decisions affect the content of textbooks sold nationwide.

Five of the eight seats on the ballot are Republican-held, setting up a unique battle within the GOP that in some races pits a bloc of Christian conservatives against challengers who believe the incumbents have pushed their pro-religious views too far.

Among those seeking re-election is former State Board of Education chairman Don McLeroy, who faced perhaps his most difficult race in his nearly 12 years on the influential panel that sets standards for Texas’ public schools. He is part of the conservative Christian bloc that controls the 15-member board, which has unusual clout because textbook publishers have few clients bigger than Texas.

The elections are the first since the board tackled evolution curriculum in 2008. During that heated debate, which ultimately led lawmakers to oust McLeroy as chairman, the board decided Texas schools would no longer have to teach the “strengths and weaknesses” of evolution. Teachers still would be encouraged to consider “all sides” of scientific theories.

Earlier this year, the board debated social studies curriculum and argued about whether figures such as human-rights activist Cesar Chavez and Thurgood Marshall, the first black Supreme Court justice, had contributed enough to American society to be included.

McLeroy defended the District 9 seat he has held since 1998 against lobbyist Thomas Ratliff, who criticized McLeroy for being too far right.

“We’re not too far any which way,” said McLeroy, a Bryan dentist. “It’s in the middle. We’re in good, clear thinking to help with our schools.”

Ratliff, the son of former Texas Lt. Gov. Bill Ratliff, is among a group of GOP challengers viewed as less partisan on culture-war issues than their incumbent opponents. Another is attorney Tim Tuggey, who is trying to unseat Ken Mercer in District 5, where four Democrats also are vying for the seat.

The successor to Cynthia Dunbar in District 10 is another closely watched race. Dunbar did not run for re-election after one term, in which she drew the most attention for having a book published in which she said public schools were a “subtly deceptive tool of perversion.”

Dunbar has endorsed Austin attorney Brian Russell, who faces educators Rebecca Osborne and Marsha Farney in the Republican primary. The winner will face educator Judy Jennings, who has no Democratic opponent in the primary.

Democrats Rene Nunez and Lawrence Allen Jr. are the two Democratic incumbents running for re-election, though Allen is unopposed in both the primary and general election and will serve a second four-year term.

No Democrats filed to run for McLeroy’s seat in the November general election.